Here's a comparison of Son of Sardaar 2 and Saiyara, focusing on reviews, box office performance, and audience reception as of July 26, 2025.
Son of Sardaar 2
Genre/Story: Comedy with Punjabi masala flavor, following Jassi's chaotic attempts to reconcile with his wife in Scotland, involving mob conflicts and Sikh wedding drama.
Cast: Ajay Devgn, Mrunal Thakur, Kubbra Sait, Ravi Kishan.
Critical Reception:
Reviews highlight a lack of originality and formulaic, recycled humor, with many comedic beats feeling stale to critics.
Some praise its nostalgic appeal for fans of the first film and bright, vibrant visuals.
Meant for fans of slapstick masala entertainers but not for those expecting evolved storytelling.
Audience Buzz: Mixed to negative online response—trailer and film feedback suggest disappointment over lack of ingenuity.
Box Office:
Originally set for July 25, postponed to August 1 to avoid a direct clash with the surging Saiyara.
Pre-release excitement considered weak, with trade analysts predicting an underwhelming opening (possibly under ₹10 crore on day 1).
No significant collection or hit status reported yet, as it has just released.
Saiyara
Genre/Story: Romantic drama by Mohit Suri, centering on young love, music, heartbreak, and reconciliation—thematically akin to earlier Mohit Suri hits like Aashiqui 2.
Cast: Ahaan Panday (debut), Aneet Padda.
Critical Reception:
Generally favorable reviews for its emotional storytelling, lead pair chemistry, and melodic soundtrack.
While the plot is familiar, critics and audiences appreciate the heartfelt performances and musical moments.
Recognized as an emotional ride, with a strong second half and memorable climax.
Audience Buzz: Massive—the film turns into a youth sensation, leading to packed theaters and an expanded show count across India.
Box Office:
Opening day collection: Estimated at ₹21.25 crore—exceptional for a romantic film with newcomers.
Increased number of shows after release due to high demand.
Continues to break box office records, outperforming many established star vehicles.
Head-to-Head: Why the Comparison?
Release Impact: Son of Sardaar 2 was delayed specifically because of Saiyara's sweeping box office and pop culture success. Industry watchers widely described this as the direct result of the "Saiyara effect".
Box Office Showdown: Saiyara's blockbuster run has reportedly dented the prospects and screen count for Son of Sardaar 2, forcing a rare strategic postponement for a big-cast film.
Critical/Fan Favor: Saiyara is winning on both critical acclaim and audience numbers, while Son of Sardaar 2 suffers from lukewarm reactions.
Table: Key Stats at a Glance
Aspect Son of Sardaar 2 Saiyara
Genre Comedy/Masala Romantic Drama
Stars Ajay Devgn, Mrunal Thakur, Ravi Kishan, Kubbra Sait Ahaan Panday, Aneet Padda
Release Plan Postponed from July 25 to August 1 due to Saiyara Released July 18
Critics’ Score Mixed to negative Positive (noted for emotion, chemistry, music)
Box Office Opening Projected under ₹10 crore ₹21.25 crore opening day
Buzz "Underwhelming," lack of originality "Blockbuster buzz," youth-driven hit
Audience Response Mixed/fan nostalgia Strong emotional connect, houseful shows
Strategic Impact Delayed to avoid box office failure due to Saiyara Expanded to more theaters; dominates July 2025 box office
In summary:
Saiyara is outperforming Son of Sardaar 2 both critically and commercially, boasting a record-breaking opening, positive reception, and a surge in popularity.
Son of Sardaar 2 has been overshadowed by Saiyara, prompting both a change in release date and muted industry expectations.
Comments
Post a Comment